The Great Amillennial Hijack
For most of my readers, we assume that it's pretty evident that God isn't done with His covenant people, the Jews. Israel coming back as a nation, after being gone for 2000 years and almost totally destroyed in the Holocaust, is about as much of a Modern Day miracle as we need. We can look at that one incredible event and equate it to God parting the Red Sea. IT COULDN'T HAVE HAPPENED UNLESS IT WAS SUPERNATURAL!
But sadly, there are many Bible-reading, God-fearing Christians who are turning on Israel in the Last Days. I will encourage you to read all the article in the link I will post. In short there is a movement called Amillennialism taking over many evangelical churches. They believe that God no longer has any plan for the Jews and Israel, that followers of Christ are the NEW chosen people, there is no rapture and that we are actually IN THE MILENNIAL REIGN OF CHRIST. They think Jesus did everything He was going to do and he is on the throne and everything is just going to get better.
Where were the two witnesses that Revelation talk about? Where were the 144,000 Jews from each of the 12 tribes of Israel? Where was the Antichrist sitting in the 3rd Temple declaring himself to be God? Where was the lion laying down with the lamb? Where were the children playing with poisonous snakes?
So many questions....but these folks just spiritualize it away and say, "All that happened when Rome destroyed Israel in 70 AD.
So read on and hold firm. Arm yourself with some of what this article points out as biblical defenses against this movement.
Dismantling N.T. Wright’s Replacement Fantasy and the Expository Reality of Romans 11
When the brilliant academic machinery of modern historicism grinds against the precision-engineered text of Holy Writ, a catastrophic structural failure is inevitable. At a recent conference in Dallas, Texas, Anglican theologian N.T. Wright took aim at Romans 11:26, dismissing the literal, national restoration and salvation of ethnic Israel as a “modern-day fantasy.” In doing so, he declared that when the Apostle Paul states “all Israel will be saved,” he actually means the mixed assembly of the Church—Judean and Gentile alike.
With all due respect to the academic credentials of the right honorable bishop, this is not merely a variance in interpretation. This is a severe hermeneutical breach. It is a classic example of allegorical replacement theology, or what some call Supercessionism, dressed up in the sophisticated garb of New Testament contextualization. This is a failure to recognize that the Bible is an integrated message system where every detail matters, and where God’s integrity is directly bound to His literal covenants.
If language has any meaning, we cannot allow the explicit promises made to the literal, genetic descendants of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob to be vaporized into abstract corporate metaphors. Let us examine the textual anatomy of Romans 11 verse-by-verse through a strict, literal, grammatico-historical hermeneutic, unpacking the underlying Hebrew (Lashon HaKodesh) and Greek (Koine) constructs, alongside deep Old Testament shadows (Typology), to see whether Paul is outlining an amillennial corporate merger or a dramatic, prophetic, dispensational rescue operation.
The Macro-Typological Blueprint: Shadows of Israel’s Blindness and Restoration
Before parsing the text of Romans 11, we must recognize that the New Testament does not exist in a structural vacuum. The New Testament is enfolded in the Old, and the Old Testament is unfolded in the New. God has pre-written the entire national history of Israel, their rejection of the Messiah, the calling of a Gentile Bride, and their ultimate national restoration into the very biographies of the Patriarchs.
The Joseph Architecture: The Hidden Messiah and the Gentile Bride
The life of Joseph is perhaps the most flawless macro-type of Yeshua HaMashiach in all of Holy Writ.
The Rejection: Joseph was rejected by his own physical brethren, the sons of Israel, who stripped him of his coat and cast him into a pit.
The Turn to the Gentiles: During the period of his rejection and separation from his brethren, Joseph was elevated to the right hand of Pharaoh in Egypt. He was given a new, foreign name—Zaphnath-Paaneah (“Revealer of Secrets” or “Savior of the World”)—and he was given a Gentile Bride, Asenath, the daughter of a priest of On (Genesis 41:45).
The Parallel: This is the current dispensation of the Church. Rejected by His literal kinsmen, Jesus has been elevated to the right hand of the Majesty on High and is currently taking a Bride predominantly from the Gentile world (the fullness of the Gentiles).
The Disclosure: Joseph did not reveal his true identity to his brethren on their first visit. It was only on their second visit, when they were in deep distress and brought to total brokenness by a manufactured crisis, that Joseph commanded every Gentile to leave the room. He wept aloud and declared in Hebrew: “Ani Yosef—Is my father yet alive?” (Genesis 45:3). This is the absolute prophetic template of the Second Advent. Jesus will not reveal Himself to national Israel until their hour of greatest tribulation, when they are brought to utter desperation. Then, and only then, will the veil be removed, and they will recognize their brother.
The Moses Model: Midian and Zipporah
When Moses offered himself as a deliverer to his Hebrew brethren, they rejected his authority, saying, “Who made thee a prince and a judge over us?” (Exodus 2:14).
Exile & Gentile Bride: Driven into exile in the wilderness of Midian, Moses turned his attention away from Israel and took a Gentile Bride, Zipporah, the daughter of a Midianite priest.
Prolonged Interim: He remained in Midian until an entire generation died and a new crisis arose under a ruthless Pharaoh.
Literal Redemption: Only after this prolonged interim—a perfect type of the Age of Grace—did God send Moses back to Egypt to accomplish the literal, physical, national redemption of Israel. If the pattern holds, the Messiah’s current focus on a Gentile assembly must be followed by a literal return to deliver His physical kinsmen.
The Textual Exposition: Romans 11:1–15
Romans 11:1–2
“I say then, Hath God cast away his people? God forbid. For I also am an Israelite, of the seed of Abraham, of the tribe of Benjamin. God hath not cast away his people which he foreknew…”
Paul begins his rhetorical cross-examination with an absolute Greek negative: Mē genoito!—an idiom meaning “May it never be!” or “Let such a thought be utterly banished from the mind!” If God had permanently substituted Israel with the Church, this would have been the precise moment for Paul to declare the finality of that substitution.
Instead, Paul introduces his own physical pedigree into evidence. He is an Israelite, of the physical spermatos Abraam (seed of Abraham), from the specific geographic phylēs Beniamin (tribe of Benjamin). This is raw, physical vocabulary that resists spiritualization.
Furthermore, Paul uses the verb proegnō (“foreknew”). In a Messianic and Hebrew context, this reflects the Yada (יָדַע) of the Old Testament—not mere passive, omniscient foresight, but an active, sovereign commitment to enter into an intimate, covenantal relationship (cf. Amos 3:2, “You only have I known of all the families of the earth”). God’s foreknowledge of ethnic Israel is anchored in His immutable character.
Romans 11:7–8
“What then? Israel hath not obtained that which he seeketh for; but the election hath obtained it, and the rest were blinded (According as it is written, God hath given them the spirit of slumber, eyes that they should not see, and ears that they should not hear;) unto this day.”
Paul here introduces a crucial theological distinction. There is “the election” (hē eklogē—the saved Jewish remnant), and there is “the rest” (hoi de loipoi—the hardened mass of national Israel). To prove this is temporary and judicially inflicted, Paul quotes Isaiah 29:10 and Deuteronomy 29:4.
He calls it a pneuma katanyxeōs—a “spirit of deep stupor” or judicial slumber. If this blindness were permanent or structural, God would be unjust to hold them accountable to an unconditional covenant. The very fact that it is a slumber implies that an hour is coming when the sleeper will be awakened.
Romans 11:11–12
“I say then, Have they stumbled that they should fall? God forbid: but rather through their fall salvation is come unto the Gentiles, for to provoke them to jealousy. Now if the fall of them be the riches of the world, and the diminishing of them the riches of the world; how much more their fulness?”
Notice the precise structural and strategic logic Paul employs. He distinguishes between a “stumble” (ptaiō) and a terminal, irreversible “fall” (piptō). The stumbling of ethnic Israel is a temporary, tactical suspension in the economy of God, not a permanent disposition.
The divine objective behind this judicial detour is to bring salvation to the Gentiles (ethnesin), explicitly eis to parazēlōsai autous—”in order to provoke them to jealousy.” This is a direct application of the Midrashic principle found in Deuteronomy 32:21, where God warned that He would move Israel to jealousy with those who are not a nation.
Paul sets up a dynamic mathematical contrast between their hēttēma (their deficit or diminishing) and their future plērōma (their absolute fullness). From a dispensational perspective, if their temporary spiritual bankruptcy brought massive wealth to the world during this interim Age of Grace, their future national restoration will bring an absolute explosion of prophetic fulfillment.
Romans 11:15
“For if the casting away of them be the reconciling of the world, what shall the receiving of them be, but life from the dead?”
While Wright correctly notes that this language implies “life from the dead,” he strips it of its literal, eschatological punch. In the Hebrew framework, “life from the dead” (chayim min hametim) points directly to Ezekiel 37—the Vision of the Dry Bones where the Ruach HaKodesh breathes life back into the dead national body of the Beit Yisrael (House of Israel).
The Greek word for “receiving” is proslēpsis, which means an aggressive, welcoming acceptance. Lexical sanity demands that the entity “cast away” (apobolē) must be the exact same entity that is “received back” (proslēpsis). The entity cast away was ethnic, national Israel; therefore, the entity received back must be ethnic, national Israel.
The Structural Reality: A Final Rebuttal
The view espoused by Wright that “all Israel” means the Church is a grammatical and contextual impossibility within Romans 9–11. Throughout these three chapters, Paul uses the word “Israel” eleven times. In every single preceding instance, “Israel” refers exclusively to ethnic, national Israel in explicit contrast to the Gentile world. To abruptly change the semantic meaning of the word in verse 26 to mean a multi-ethnic Church is an interpretive parlor trick that violates basic literary sanity.
We must let the plain sense of Scripture make common sense, lest we end up with structural nonsense. The Bible does not teach a generic, muddy mixture of identities where Israel is spiritualized out of existence. It teaches a flawless, Biblical blueprint: Israel is temporarily set aside while God calls out a bride from among the nations. When that work is finished, the Church is caught up, and God turns His programmatic focus back to the literal, national restoration of His covenant people.
N.T. Wright calls this a “modern-day fantasy.” We call it the unshakeable, literal veracity of the Word of the Living God. Maranatha.
Here; The Great Amillennial Hijack: By Travis A. Karnes - Rapture Ready
I did NOT post the entire article, so again, I encourage you to read it all at the link above.
Remember, it's the CHURCH that is grafted into Israel. God is NOT done with them, but they have experienced a temporary blindness so that "the fullness of the gentiles can come in", to a relationship with God via Jesus Christ. Once Jesus comes for his bride at the rapture, God will then turn his attention back to His covenant people. There will be "The Time of Jacob's Trouble" during the final 7 years and Zechariah 13 mentions that 2/3 of the Jews will die, most in horrendous ways at the hands of the Antichrist.
Keep looking up! Jesus IS coming for His bride!